Feature
Tile Roofing
Architectural Shingle
Standing Seam Metal
Expected life in Tampa Bay
Tile Roofing
50 years for the tile, 25 to 30 for the underlayment
Architectural Shingle
20 to 25 years
Standing Seam Metal
40 to 60 years
Installed cost per square foot
Tile Roofing
$12 to $18 concrete, $15 to $25 clay
Architectural Shingle
$4.50 to $8
Standing Seam Metal
$10 to $18
Weight per square
Tile Roofing
600 to 1,100 pounds
Architectural Shingle
200 to 350 pounds
Standing Seam Metal
100 to 150 pounds
Wind performance
Tile Roofing
Excellent when fastened to the manual; individual tiles can shed
Architectural Shingle
Good with six nails and sealed deck
Standing Seam Metal
Excellent, concealed fasteners
Insurance discount
Tile Roofing
Strong with sealed deck
Architectural Shingle
Good with sealed deck
Standing Seam Metal
Strong with sealed deck
Look
Tile Roofing
Mediterranean, Spanish, coastal, HOA standard on the waterfront
Architectural Shingle
Traditional
Standing Seam Metal
Modern and coastal
Best for
Tile Roofing
Owners staying 20 plus years, HOAs that require it, homes with framing rated for it
Architectural Shingle
Budget and resale within 15 years
Standing Seam Metal
Waterfront, longevity, low maintenance